[Nick]
Out of the rain, looking for sunshine
I call your name, but you’re like a ghost
I let you disappear, should’ve never let you go
I want to say just for the record

That you still got my heart and my soul
You know we’re worlds apart, yeah I’ve got to let you know

[Howie]
You are the piece I can’t replace, oh
You left a mark that won’t erase, no

[All]
No one else can teach me how to love again
‘Cause you left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it
Nevermind what people say ’cause they don’t understand
How you left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it

[A.J.]

Some try to break through the walls
…but they don’t compare to you
One chance, I swear I’ll never let you go

[A.J./Brian]
You are the piece I can’t replace, oh
You left a mark that won’t erase, no

[All]
No one else can teach me how to love again
‘Cause you left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it
Nevermind what people say ’cause they don’t understand
How you left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it

Ooh ooh ooh ooh

You left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it

[Kevin]
One should… with time
Never gonna fade, one can touch the flame and tame the fire
You are the piece I can’t replace, oh
You left a mark that won’t erase, no

[All]
No one else can teach me how to love again
‘Cause you left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it
Nevermind what people say ’cause they don’t understand
How you left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it

Ooh ooh ooh ooh
You left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it
Ooh ooh ooh ooh
You left a permanent stain on my heart and I’ve been feeling it